Re-roof · 2 quotes · 2 letters
A letter to each builder
Send each builder their letter before you choose. The answers, and how clearly each builder gives them, are part of the choice.
Each letter covers only that builder’s own quote. It never names another builder or quotes another price.
Your letter to Ashby
The questions
All 9 questions are in the letter.
6 come from the things to settle with Ashby, and 3 are points we add to every re-roof letter. Untick any you have already settled, or would rather ask in person.
Send it yourself
We never send a letter for you. Copy it into an email or a message, and it goes from you.
Once it has gone, mark it as sent. We keep that version exactly as it is.
[Your name]
[Your address]
23 October
Ashby Roofing Ltd
Re: your quotation for re-roofing, dated 13 October
Dear Ashby Roofing,
Thank you for your quotation. Before we decide, we’d be grateful if you could confirm the points below.
- 1Could we pay a smaller deposit to book the date, and pay for materials when they arrive?From page 6: the deposit, 30% on acceptance
- 2Who will notify Building Control or register the work under a competent person scheme, and will we receive the certificate when the roof is finished?Building Regulations sign-off: not mentioned anywhere in the 7 pages
- 3What day rate applies to timber repairs found once the old tiles are off, and will you agree each repair with us before doing it?From page 5: timber repairs at a day rate, £600–£1,500
- 4Is the 10-year guarantee backed by insurance, and does it pass to a new owner if we sell?From page 7: the 10-year guarantee
- 5Could you confirm the start date and how many working days the job will take?Start date and length of the job: not mentioned anywhere in the 7 pages
- 6How is the price affected if bad weather extends the job?From page 6: weather delays ‘may incur additional charges’
- 7Could you send a copy of your public liability insurance certificate?Added to every re-roof letter
- 8How will the house be kept watertight while the roof is open?Added to every re-roof letter
- 9Will the scaffolding stay up for the whole job at no extra hire cost if the work overruns?Added to every re-roof letter. Scaffolding is included on page 3.
Thank you for your time. We look forward to hearing from you.
Kind regards,
[Your name]
Before you sign
What is still open with Ashby, and the paperwork to have in hand. We do not read replies, so nothing here is ticked off for you.
Things to settle with Ashby: 6
- Worth askingThe deposit: 30% on acceptance£4,140
Ashby’s words, page 6
- RegulationBuilding Regulations sign-off is not namedPaperwork
Not mentioned anywhere in the 7 pages.
- Worth askingTimber repairs: estimated, but the day rate is not written down£600–£1,500
Ashby’s words, page 5
- Worth askingThe 10-year guarantee: who stands behind it10 years
Ashby’s words, page 7
- Worth askingNo start date or length of jobNo dates
Not mentioned anywhere in the 7 pages.
- Worth askingWeather delays ‘may incur additional charges’Not stated
Ashby’s words, page 6
Each is a question in your letter to Ashby. Ashby’s words or where they are missing, why it matters and the question are in Ashby’s section of the report.
Paperwork to have before you sign
The contract, with the payment stages written in
Ashby’s quote asks 30%, £4,140, on acceptance, page 6, and the balance of £9,660 on completion. The contract should match what you agree.
The insurance certificate
Public liability insurance in Ashby Roofing Ltd’s name, in date on the day the work starts.
Who obtains Building Regulations sign-off
Not named anywhere in Ashby’s 7 pages. Who notifies Building Control, or registers the work, is worth having in writing.
When the work is finished
You will need these when you sell.
The completion certificate
From the competent person scheme, or from Building Control if the work was notified there.
The guarantee
Ashby’s 10-year guarantee, page 7, in writing, and whether it is backed by insurance and passes to a new owner.
Your letter to Kestrel
The questions
All 9 questions are in the letter.
6 come from the things to settle with Kestrel, 1 from what Kestrel’s quote leaves out in writing, and 2 are points we add to every re-roof letter. Untick any you have already settled, or would rather ask in person.
Send it yourself
We never send a letter for you. Copy it into an email or a message, and it goes from you.
Once it has gone, mark it as sent. We keep that version exactly as it is.
[Your name]
[Your address]
23 October
Kestrel Roofing
Re: your quotation for re-roofing, dated 22 October
Dear Kestrel Roofing,
Thank you for your quotation. Before we decide, we’d be grateful if you could confirm the points below.
- 1Is scaffolding included in the £11,600? If not, what will it cost, and who arranges it?Scaffolding: not mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages
- 2Your quote says you are a member of a competent person scheme. Which scheme is it, will you register this job through it, and will we receive the certificate when the roof is finished?From page 3: scheme membership is stated, the certificate is not
- 3Page 2 says rotten timbers will be replaced at cost. Could you give us a day rate, and agree each repair with us before you do it?From page 2: rotten timbers ‘replaced at cost’
- 4Page 1 says the old felt and battens come off. Which membrane and battens will you fit in their place?From page 1: a new membrane and battens are not named
- 5Is the 5-year guarantee backed by insurance, and does it pass to a new owner if we sell?From page 3: the 5-year guarantee
- 6Page 1 says the ridge and verges will be re-bedded in mortar. Will they also be mechanically fixed, as BS 5534 expects, and if that is not in the £11,600, what would it add?From page 1: the ridge and verges re-bedded in mortar, with no fixings stated
- 7Your quote leaves out the skip, at £350. Could you arrange it at that price, or should we book our own?From page 2: the skip, excluded in writing, their figure £350
- 8Could you send a copy of your public liability insurance certificate?Added to every re-roof letter
- 9How will the house be kept watertight while the roof is open?Added to every re-roof letter
Thank you for your time. We look forward to hearing from you.
Kind regards,
[Your name]
Before you sign
What is still open with Kestrel, and the paperwork to have in hand. We do not read replies, so nothing here is ticked off for you.
Things to settle with Kestrel: 6
- Not mentionedScaffoldingNo separate price
Not mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages.
- RegulationScheme membership is stated, but not the certificatePaperwork
Kestrel’s words, page 3
- Worth askingRotten timbers ‘replaced at cost’, with no rateNo rate
Kestrel’s words, page 2
- Not mentionedA new membrane and battens are not namedNot named
A new membrane and new battens are not mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages.
- Worth askingThe 5-year guarantee: who stands behind it5 years
Kestrel’s words, page 3
- Worth askingThe ridge and verges appear to rely on mortar aloneFixing not stated
Mechanical fixing is not mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages.
Each is a question in your letter to Kestrel. Kestrel’s words or where they are missing, why it matters and the question are in Kestrel’s section of the report.
Paperwork to have before you sign
The contract, with the payment stages written in
Kestrel’s quote asks for the full £11,600 on completion, page 3. The contract should say the same.
The insurance certificate
Public liability insurance in Kestrel Roofing’s name, in date on the day the work starts.
Who obtains Building Regulations sign-off
Kestrel says on page 3 that they belong to a competent person scheme, which would let them register the work themselves. Worth having in writing.
When the work is finished
You will need these when you sell.
The completion certificate
From the competent person scheme, or from Building Control if the work was notified there.
The guarantee
Kestrel’s 5-year guarantee, page 3, in writing, and whether it is backed by insurance and passes to a new owner.