Ashby costs £450–£1,850 more on the same work, depending on Kestrel’s scaffolding, names every material, and asks for 30% before work starts.
Sample report. An invented re-roof with two invented builders, Ashby Roofing Ltd and Kestrel Roofing, read the way we read yours. This is everything the £14.99 full report covers.
Your re-roof · Full report · 23 October
- Quote 1 of 2 Ashby Roofing Ltd
- Quote 2 of 2 Kestrel Roofing
- Quote 1 of 2 Ashby Roofing Ltd
9 questions, dated 23 October.
Open your letter to Ashby - Quote 2 of 2 Kestrel Roofing
9 questions, dated 23 October.
Open your letter to Kestrel
Send each builder their letter before you choose. We never send them ourselves.
Re-roof · 2 quotes read · Full report · 23 October
If Kestrel’s price leaves out scaffolding, these two quotes are
less than £1,000 apart on the same work.
As quoted, Ashby Roofing Ltd asks £13,800 and Kestrel Roofing £11,600. Kestrel’s price leaves out the skip, and its 3 pages do not say whether scaffolding is included. If it is not, the gap on the same work is £450–£950; if it is, £1,850.
As quoted £2,200 apart
If scaffolding is extra £450–£950 apart
If scaffolding is included £1,850 apart
What the choice turns on
Three differences, the one that moves the price most first.
Scaffolding. Ashby’s price includes it. Kestrel’s 3 pages do not mention it, so it may not be in their £11,600. It appears to be the largest part of the £2,200 between the two totals.
Ashby, page 3 · Kestrel, pages 1 to 3 · Kestrel’s scaffolding, in full
When you pay. Ashby asks for 30%, £4,140, when you accept. Kestrel asks for nothing until the work is finished.
Ashby, page 6 · Kestrel, page 3 · Ashby’s deposit, in full
How much is written down. Ashby prices each item and names each material across 7 pages. Kestrel gives one price for the roof on 3 pages and names the tile, so the membrane and battens are worth confirming in writing.
Ashby, pages 2 to 5 · Kestrel, pages 1 and 2 · Kestrel’s membrane and battens, in full
Side by side
Each question answered for both builders, in the order the quotes arrived, with where each answer comes from.
What is the total?
Ashby, page 7
Headed ‘Quotation’, page 1 · total, page 3
Where does each sit locally?
Ashby Roofing Ltd £13,800 as quoted
Kestrel Roofing £11,600 as quoted · £12,850–£13,350 on the same work, if scaffolding is extra
Basis: regional re-roofing rates for a semi-detached house near SK4. The area is from the site address on page 1 of Ashby’s quote.
Is scaffolding included?
Front and back, with a loading bay, page 3
Our estimate from regional rates near SK4. Question 1 in your letter to Kestrel.
Who pays for the skip?
With taking the waste away, page 4
Kestrel, page 2
Are the fascias and gutters included?
‘Not included in this quotation’, page 4
Page 1 covers the roof covering only
Neither quote includes them, so neither figure on the same work does.
How are the ridge and verges fixed?
Ashby, page 2. A dry system is fixed mechanically, without mortar.
Kestrel, page 1. Question 6 in your letter to Kestrel.
Both quotes include the ridge and verges, so neither figure on the same work adds anything for them.
When do you pay?
Ashby, page 6
Kestrel, page 3
What guarantee comes with it?
Ashby, page 7
Kestrel, page 3
Neither says whether an insurer stands behind it.
What can only be priced once work starts?
Timber repairs at a day rate: their estimate, page 5
Timber repairs at cost, page 2. They give no figure, so this is our estimate from regional rates.
Neither figure on the same work includes timber repairs, because neither builder can price them exactly until the old tiles are off.
On the same work
As quoted: scaffolding and the skip are in it; neither quote includes fascias or timber repairs
£11,600, plus the skip at their £350 and scaffolding at £900–£1,400. £11,950 if scaffolding is already in the price.
Every missing item is costed. If scaffolding is not in Kestrel’s price, Kestrel is £450–£950 cheaper for the same work; if it is, £1,850 cheaper.
What this means
The trade-offs, one builder at a time, and what your letters could change. The choice is yours.
Kestrel costs less on the same work and asks for nothing until the roof is finished, but leaves the scaffolding, the membrane and the battens to be confirmed in writing.
What the answers could change
Kestrel’s scaffolding. If it is already in their £11,600, the same work costs £11,950 with Kestrel, and the difference becomes £1,850.
Question 1 in your letter to Kestrel
Ashby’s deposit. If Ashby takes £1,380 to book the date and £2,760 when the materials arrive, you pay £1,380 rather than £4,140 before anything reaches site.
Question 1 in your letter to Ashby · the split is under Ashby’s price and payments
The guarantees. Ashby’s runs for 10 years and Kestrel’s for 5. One backed by insurance still pays out if the firm stops trading.
Question 4 to Ashby · question 5 to Kestrel
Both prices sit within the local range. Send each builder their letter before you choose: the answers, and how clearly each builder gives them, are part of the choice.
Ashby Roofing Ltd, quote 1 of 2
Ashby Roofing Ltd includes the scaffolding and prices every item separately, but asks for 30% when you accept.
- Total
- £13,800including VAT, fixed price
Ashby, page 7
- On the same work
- £13,800as quoted
Scaffolding and the skip are in it
- Paid before work starts
- £4,14030%, on acceptance
Ashby, page 6
- Local range
- £11,500–£15,000Within the range in its upper half
Things to settle with Ashby: 6
2 in price and payments, 1 in regulations and paperwork, 1 in materials and guarantee and 2 in contract and your rights. Each one is a question in your letter.
Settle these first
- 1The deposit: 30% on acceptancePrice and payments · £4,140 · question 1
- 2Building Regulations sign-off is not namedRegulations and paperwork · question 2
- 3Timber repairs: estimated, but the day rate is not written downPrice and payments · £600–£1,500 · question 3
Price and payments
2 things to settle‘30% deposit payable on acceptance.’
On acceptance means £4,140 is paid before any materials arrive or any work begins. A smaller deposit to book the date, with materials paid for on delivery, is common for a roof of this size.
Could we pay a smaller deposit to book the date, and pay for materials when they arrive?
This is question 1 in your letter to Ashby.
‘Replacement of any defective timbers found after stripping will be charged at our day rate plus materials, estimated at £600–£1,500.’
Nobody can see the timbers until the old tiles are off, so a provisional figure is normal, and Ashby gives one. The day rate itself is not written down, and nothing says you will be asked before a repair goes ahead.
What day rate applies to timber repairs found once the old tiles are off, and will you agree each repair with us before doing it?
This is question 3 in your letter to Ashby.
The payment schedule
| Stage | Ashby’s schedule | A split you could suggestYou could suggest |
|---|---|---|
| On acceptance | £4,14030% | £1,38010% |
| When the materials arrive | Nothing | £2,76020% |
| On completion | £9,66070% | £9,66070% |
| Total | £13,800 | £13,800 |
The first payment comes before anything arrives on site. The split on the right keeps the total, with £1,380 to book the date, £2,760 when the materials are delivered and £9,660 on completion.
Basis: Ashby’s quote. The suggested split is ours, a common pattern for a job of this size. Suggesting it is question 1 in your letter.
What the work covers
Nothing to settleIncluded, at Ashby’s own prices
| Item | Page | Before VAT |
|---|---|---|
| Scaffolding to the front and back, with a loading bay | 3 | £1,000 |
| Stripping the old tiles, felt and battens | 2 | £1,250 |
| A breathable membrane and new treated battens | 2 | £1,400 |
| New concrete interlocking tiles, supplied and fixed | 2 | £5,600 |
| Dry ridge and dry verge systems | 2 | £900 |
| New lead flashings at the chimney | 3 | £850 |
| The skip, and taking the waste away | 4 | £500 |
| Before VAT | £11,500 | |
| VAT at 20% | £2,300 | |
| Total | 7 | £13,800 |
Every price is Ashby’s own, as written. Not in the total: timber repairs as found, their estimate £600–£1,500, page 5.
Excluded in writing
- Fascias, soffits and gutters£1,400–£2,600
‘Fascias, soffits and guttering are not included in this quotation’, page 4. Likely needed: maybe. We cannot see them from a quote; if they are worn, the scaffolding will already be up. Figure from regional rates near SK4, including VAT.
Not mentioned
Nothing missing from the work itself. Every part of the roof is priced somewhere in the 7 pages. The sign-off and the dates are under Regulations and paperwork, and under Contract and your rights.
Regulations and paperwork
1 thing to settleNot mentioned anywhere in the 7 pages.
Replacing a whole roof covering is building work under the Building Regulations. Either the roofer registers it through a competent person scheme, or someone gives notice to Building Control before work starts. Either way you should receive a certificate when the roof is finished, and a buyer’s solicitor will ask for it when you sell.
Who will notify Building Control or register the work under a competent person scheme, and will we receive the certificate when the roof is finished?
This is question 2 in your letter to Ashby.
Reference: the Building Regulations 2010, regulation 12 and schedule 3.
Who handles each regulation
- Building Regulations sign-off
- Not named anywhere in the 7 pages.Question 2 in your letter to Ashby
- Insurance while the work is done
- Not mentioned in the quote.Question 7 in your letter to Ashby
- The guarantee
- 10 years on workmanship, page 7. Insurance backing is not stated.Question 4 in your letter to Ashby
The same, for both builders side by side, is under Regulations for the project.
Materials and guarantee
1 thing to settle‘All workmanship guaranteed for 10 years from completion.’
A guarantee from the firm lasts only as long as the firm. An insurance-backed guarantee still pays out if the firm stops trading, and it usually passes to a buyer. Page 7 does not say which this is.
Is the 10-year guarantee backed by insurance, and does it pass to a new owner if we sell?
This is question 4 in your letter to Ashby.
Contract and your rights
2 things to settleNot mentioned anywhere in the 7 pages.
A start date and a number of working days are usual in a quote this detailed. Without them in writing, it is harder to agree when the job is running late, and the scaffolding stays up for as long as the job takes.
Could you confirm the start date and how many working days the job will take?
This is question 5 in your letter to Ashby.
Reference: the Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 52: where no time is agreed, the work must be done within a reasonable time.
‘Any delays caused by adverse weather may incur additional charges.’
The price is fixed, but this line leaves the cost of a wet week open. It appears to mean scaffolding hire running on, which question 9 also covers. What the charges would be, and how they are worked out, is not stated.
How is the price affected if bad weather extends the job?
This is question 6 in your letter to Ashby.
What reads well
Every item is priced separately, and the prices add up to the total on page 7.
The 10-year guarantee is in writing on page 7.
The scaffolding is described front and back, with a loading bay, on page 3.
Your letter to Ashby
9 questionsQuestions 1 to 6 come from the 6 things to settle, the first three in the order to settle them. Questions 7 to 9 are worth asking any roofer.
[Your name]
[Your address]
23 October
Ashby Roofing Ltd
Re: your quotation for re-roofing, dated 13 October
Dear Ashby Roofing,
Thank you for your quotation. Before we decide, we’d be grateful if you could confirm the points below.
- 1Could we pay a smaller deposit to book the date, and pay for materials when they arrive?
- 2Who will notify Building Control or register the work under a competent person scheme, and will we receive the certificate when the roof is finished?
- 3What day rate applies to timber repairs found once the old tiles are off, and will you agree each repair with us before doing it?
- 4Is the 10-year guarantee backed by insurance, and does it pass to a new owner if we sell?
- 5Could you confirm the start date and how many working days the job will take?
- 6How is the price affected if bad weather extends the job?
- 7Could you send a copy of your public liability insurance certificate?
- 8How will the house be kept watertight while the roof is open?
- 9Will the scaffolding stay up for the whole job at no extra hire cost if the work overruns?
Thank you for your time. We look forward to hearing from you.
Kind regards,
[Your name]
There you can copy it, send it from your own email and mark it as sent. We never send it ourselves.
Kestrel Roofing, quote 2 of 2
Kestrel Roofing leaves the skip to you, and says so clearly, but does not mention scaffolding anywhere in its 3 pages.
- Total
- £11,600including VAT, appears to be fixed
Headed ‘Quotation’, page 1 · total, page 3
- On the same work
- £12,850–£13,350if scaffolding is extra
Their skip at £350, our scaffolding at £900–£1,400. £11,950 if scaffolding is in the price.
- Paid before work starts
- Nothingall on completion
Kestrel, page 3
- Local range
- £11,500–£15,000Within the range as quoted, and on the same work
Things to settle with Kestrel: 6
1 in price and payments, 2 in what the work covers, 1 in regulations and paperwork and 2 in materials and guarantee. Each one is a question in your letter.
Settle these first
- 1ScaffoldingWhat the work covers · we allowed £900–£1,400 · question 1
- 2Scheme membership is stated, but not the certificateRegulations and paperwork · question 2
- 3Rotten timbers ‘replaced at cost’, with no ratePrice and payments · question 3
Price and payments
1 thing to settle‘Any rotten timbers to be replaced at cost.’
Nobody can see the timbers until the old tiles are off, so an open item is normal. ‘At cost’ gives no rate and no limit, and nothing says you will be asked before a repair goes ahead. Repairs on a roof of this age often come to £600–£1,500, from regional rates.
Page 2 says rotten timbers will be replaced at cost. Could you give us a day rate, and agree each repair with us before you do it?
This is question 3 in your letter to Kestrel.
The payment schedule
| Stage | Kestrel’s schedule |
|---|---|
| On acceptance | Nothing |
| On completion | £11,600100% |
| Total | £11,600 |
One payment, when the work is finished. You pay nothing before the roof is on.
Basis: Kestrel, page 3. Not in this total: the skip at £350, page 2, and timber repairs at cost, page 2.
What the work covers
2 things to settleNot mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages.
A re-roof on a two-storey semi needs scaffolding along the front and the back. It may be in the £11,600 and simply not written down. If it is not, it is a separate cost: on the same work we allowed £900–£1,400 for it, from regional rates near SK4.
Is scaffolding included in the £11,600? If not, what will it cost, and who arranges it?
This is question 1 in your letter to Kestrel.
‘Strip existing tiles, felt and battens and re-tile.’
A new membrane and new battens are not mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages.
The membrane keeps out the water that gets past the tiles, and the battens hold the tiles on. Page 1 has the old ones coming off, so new ones must go back, and the quote does not say which. A breathable membrane and treated battens are usual.
Page 1 says the old felt and battens come off. Which membrane and battens will you fit in their place?
This is question 4 in your letter to Kestrel.
Included
- Stripping the old tiles, felt and battenspage 1
- New concrete tiles, named by make and colourpage 1
- Re-bedding the ridge and verges in mortarpage 1
- New lead flashings at the chimneypage 1
- Timber repairs as found, at costpage 2
Kestrel gives one price for the work, £11,600 including VAT on page 3, so there are no item prices to show. Whether the ridge and verges are also fixed mechanically is question 6 in your letter, under materials and guarantee.
Excluded in writing
- The skip£350
‘Skip hire not included, approx. £350’, page 2. Likely needed: yes. Their figure.
Not mentioned
- Scaffolding£900–£1,400
Not mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages. We allowed this on the same work, from regional rates near SK4, including VAT. Question 1 in your letter.
- A new membrane and battensNo allowance
Page 1 has the old ones coming off. Fitting new ones is part of re-tiling, so we added nothing; which ones is question 4 in your letter.
Regulations and paperwork
1 thing to settle‘All work carried out by a member of a competent person scheme.’
Kestrel says on page 3 that they belong to a competent person scheme, which would let them register the work themselves, without a visit from Building Control. The quote does not name the scheme, say they will register this job, or say that you will receive the certificate, which you will need when you sell.
Your quote says you are a member of a competent person scheme. Which scheme is it, will you register this job through it, and will we receive the certificate when the roof is finished?
This is question 2 in your letter to Kestrel.
Reference: the Building Regulations 2010, schedule 3.
Who handles each regulation
- Building Regulations sign-off
- Kestrel says it is a member of a competent person scheme, page 3, but does not name the scheme. The certificate is not mentioned.Question 2 in your letter to Kestrel
- Insurance while the work is done
- Not mentioned in the quote.Question 8 in your letter to Kestrel
- The guarantee
- 5 years on workmanship, page 3. Insurance backing is not stated.Question 5 in your letter to Kestrel
The same, for both builders side by side, is under Regulations for the project.
Materials and guarantee
2 things to settle‘5 year guarantee on all workmanship.’
A guarantee from the firm lasts only as long as the firm. An insurance-backed guarantee still pays out if the firm stops trading, and it usually passes to a buyer. Page 3 does not say which this is.
Is the 5-year guarantee backed by insurance, and does it pass to a new owner if we sell?
This is question 5 in your letter to Kestrel.
‘Re-bed ridge and verges in mortar.’
Mechanical fixing is not mentioned anywhere in the 3 pages.
BS 5534, the British Standard for tiling a roof, expects every ridge and verge tile to be fixed mechanically, with clips or screws, rather than held by mortar alone, because mortar can crack and let tiles work loose in high winds. Page 1 mentions mortar and no fixings, so the ridge and verges appear to be left to mortar alone. Fixings may be intended and simply not written down.
Page 1 says the ridge and verges will be re-bedded in mortar. Will they also be mechanically fixed, as BS 5534 expects, and if that is not in the £11,600, what would it add?
This is question 6 in your letter to Kestrel.
Reference: BS 5534:2014, the code of practice for slating and tiling pitched roofs.
Contract and your rights
Nothing to settleThe start date and the length of the job are in writing on page 3: the week of 10 November, about 5 working days.
What reads well
Nothing is paid until the work is finished, as page 3 sets out, and the tile is named by make and colour on page 1.
The skip is left to you, and the quote says so plainly, with their own figure of £350 on page 2.
The start date and the length of the job are in writing: the week of 10 November, about 5 working days, on page 3.
Your letter to Kestrel
9 questionsQuestions 1 to 6 come from the 6 things to settle, the first three in the order to settle them. Question 7 follows from the skip they exclude on page 2. Questions 8 and 9 are worth asking any roofer.
[Your name]
[Your address]
23 October
Kestrel Roofing
Re: your quotation for re-roofing, dated 22 October
Dear Kestrel Roofing,
Thank you for your quotation. Before we decide, we’d be grateful if you could confirm the points below.
- 1Is scaffolding included in the £11,600? If not, what will it cost, and who arranges it?
- 2Your quote says you are a member of a competent person scheme. Which scheme is it, will you register this job through it, and will we receive the certificate when the roof is finished?
- 3Page 2 says rotten timbers will be replaced at cost. Could you give us a day rate, and agree each repair with us before you do it?
- 4Page 1 says the old felt and battens come off. Which membrane and battens will you fit in their place?
- 5Is the 5-year guarantee backed by insurance, and does it pass to a new owner if we sell?
- 6Page 1 says the ridge and verges will be re-bedded in mortar. Will they also be mechanically fixed, as BS 5534 expects, and if that is not in the £11,600, what would it add?
- 7Your quote leaves out the skip, at £350. Could you arrange it at that price, or should we book our own?
- 8Could you send a copy of your public liability insurance certificate?
- 9How will the house be kept watertight while the roof is open?
Thank you for your time. We look forward to hearing from you.
Kind regards,
[Your name]
There you can copy it, send it from your own email and mark it as sent. We never send it ourselves.
Regulations for the project
For the project, whichever builder you choose, with who handles each one.
Building Regulations sign-off
Replacing a whole roof covering is building work under the Building Regulations. The roofer registers it through a competent person scheme, or someone gives notice to Building Control before work starts. You should receive a certificate at the end.
Who handles it
- Ashby Roofing Ltd
- Not named anywhere in the 7 pages.Question 2 in your letter to Ashby
- Kestrel Roofing
- Kestrel says it is a member of a competent person scheme, page 3, but does not name the scheme. The certificate is not mentioned.Question 2 in your letter to Kestrel
Insurance while the work is done
A roofer working at height on your house should hold public liability insurance. It is usual to see a copy of the certificate before work starts.
Who handles it
- Ashby Roofing Ltd
- Not mentioned in the quote.Question 7 in your letter to Ashby
- Kestrel Roofing
- Not mentioned in the quote.Question 8 in your letter to Kestrel
The guarantee
A written guarantee is part of the paperwork you keep. One backed by insurance still pays out if the firm stops trading.
Who handles it
- Ashby Roofing Ltd
- 10 years on workmanship, page 7. Insurance backing is not stated.Question 4 in your letter to Ashby
- Kestrel Roofing
- 5 years on workmanship, page 3. Insurance backing is not stated.Question 5 in your letter to Kestrel
Paperwork to collect
Before you sign
- The quote you accept, with the payment stages written in
- The builder’s public liability insurance certificate
- Who obtains Building Regulations sign-off, in writing
When the work is finished
- The Building Regulations certificate
- The guarantee, with the insurer’s name if it is backed by insurance
- A receipt for the final payment
Keep them together. The certificate and the guarantee are what a buyer’s solicitor asks for when you sell.
Your letters
One letter per builder, each with that builder’s own questions, ready to send before you choose.
- Quote 1 of 2 Ashby Roofing Ltd
9 questions, dated 23 October.
Open your letter to Ashby - Quote 2 of 2 Kestrel Roofing
9 questions, dated 23 October.
Open your letter to Kestrel
Send each builder their letter before you choose. We never send them ourselves.
About this report
What it rests on, and the dated record to keep.
What we read
- Quote 1 of 2 Ashby Roofing Ltd
- Quote dated 13 October. 7 pages, uploaded as a PDF. £13,800 including VAT.
- Quote 2 of 2 Kestrel Roofing
- Quote dated 22 October. 3 pages, photographed. £11,600 including VAT.
- The job
- Re-roof of a 1930s semi-detached house, as both quotes describe it.
- The area
- SK4, from the site address on page 1 of Ashby’s quote.
- Local rates
- Regional re-roofing rates for a semi-detached house near SK4, used for the local range and for every allowance.
The dated record
The PDF is this report as it reads on 23 October, with both letters at the end. A copy came with your receipt email. Keep it with the quote you sign.
Not available on the sample.
This report is our reading of the documents you gave us, set against regional rates. It is not legal advice. We never contact your builders.